Solar lobby, industry and NGOs make last push to shape Germany’s renewables reform
Clean Energy Wire
Industry groups and environmentalists in Germany launched a new push to influence the reform of the country’s Renewable Energy Act (EEG) on the last stretch of a mandatory overhaul of the law, which needs to be completed before the end of the year to comply with EU state aid rules. Solar lobby group BSW Solar argued for a continued support for small rooftop solar installations, which the economy ministry had sought to scrap but which coalition lawmakers now appear set to keep, while influential industry group BDI urged the government to stick to its aim of cutting costs, and environmental NGOs warned against an expansion of biogas support.
“Supporting new small rooftop solar installations is much less of a burden to the electricity system than many think,” said BSW Solar, citing an analysis by research institute EWI that found a typical new installation on a family home needs support of only 0.8 cents per kilowatt-hour generated. If the costs for support and for grid expansion are both taken into account, rooftop solar has no significant cost disadvantage compared to ground-mounted systems, according to BSW Solar.
The solar power industry group welcomed a preliminary agreement between energy experts of the two coalition parties, announced last week by the Social Democrats (SPD), to keep feed-in tariffs for rooftop solar installations of up to 25 kilowatts. The SPD is the junior partner of chancellor Friedrich Merz’s conservative Christian Democrats (CDU). CDU economy minister Katherina had planned to end permanent fixed payments for such installations in a draft the cabinet approved in July, alongside steps to slow renewables expansion in areas with a higher risk of grid bottlenecks, as part of a bid to bring down energy system costs.
Rooftop installations have accounted for around half of Germany’s solar power additions in recent years, and solar has become one of the country’s largest power sources. Germany aims to cover 80 percent of its electricity consumption with renewables by 2030, but the government argues that rising grid and support costs require more targeted expansion.
A final decision on the reform of the EEG, which regulates support for renewable power installations, through guaranteed payments over 20 years, is expected by mid-December. The current funding regime expires at the end of 2026, and renewable industry groups have warned of an investment gap from January if the reform is delayed. The coalition parties have said they aim to agree on the EEG reform together with a grid package, which will regulate new connections to an electricity grid that struggles to cope with the transformation after upgrades were delayed for years.
BSW Solar said the economy ministry’s initial proposal would have throttled the energy transition and put tens of thousands of jobs in the solar industry at risk without increasing cost efficiency. “If you want to lower energy costs, you have to pull the right levers,” said BSW Solar head Carsten Körnig. “The largest saving potentials lie in a smarter use of our power grids – not in putting the brakes on solar citizen energy,” he said
By contrast, the Federation of German Industries (BDI) said the government should not make the mistake of “overburdening the reform package with particular interests” and should stick to its plan to cut support for small rooftop solar installations as well as capping support for biogas plants. “This very reform threatens to be watered down on the last metres,” said BDI deputy director general Holger Lösch. He said the government had initiated important steps towards making electricity prices more competitive and that the initially envisaged EEG reform would lower system costs long-term.
“The government must hold the course now: system costs down instead of support costs up,” Lösch said, adding that both the EEG reform and the grid package should focus on cost efficiency. Short-term measures, such as cutting the country’s electricity tax, would otherwise become “a bridge to nowhere,” he added.
Environmental NGO umbrella group DNR also criticised the planned reform, saying the extended support for biogas would cost a lot of money and consume large areas and other environmental resources. “About 1.5 million hectares of land in Germany are being used to grow energy crops for biogas production already today, mainly for maize,” said DNR head Kai Niebert. Government plans to increase support and allow for a doubling of the maize shares in biogas would bring the risk of even more monocultures, competition for land and loss of biodiversity, he said.
“We must not organise the energy transition at the expense of the environment,” Niebert said. While biogas can be produced sustainably from residual materials from agriculture and can make power supply more flexible, creating new incentives to devote farmland to energy production would not make sense from an economic or ecologic perspective, he argued. Niebert said the government parties should split up their negotiations on the EEG reform and the grid package to ensure the former is adopted quickly and to prevent a disruption to renewable power investments in early 2027.
