German wind industry worries about public resistance as installations slump
A sharp rise in legal challenges to new onshore wind power projects has become a serious hurdle for the further roll-out of the technology in Germany, the German Wind Energy Association (BWE) and the German Engineering Federation’s (VDMA) Power Systems said.
“A permit does no longer create legal certainty, because practically every new permit is now contested in court,” said the BWE’s Wolfram Axthelm at the industry’s annual review press conference.
Axthelm added that opposition to the construction of new wind turbines had become increasingly professional, with national resistance groups like vernunftkraft and specialised lawyers reaching out to local residents with proposals to fight projects in court, mostly with lawsuits related to species conservation.
Court cases related to species conservation have also been used by green groups to fight major fossil fuel projects. Late last year, a court stopped the controversial clearing of the embattled Hambach Forest to make way for a coal mine after Environmental NGO Friends of the Earth Germany (BUND) had filed a lawsuit relating to the protection of rare bat species.
“Local residents have to become more involved in planning decentralised energy production,” Axthelm said. “29,000 wind turbines are simply much more visible” than Germany’s power plants, he added.
Powering green industry projects
Matthias Zelinger, General Manager at VDMA Power Systems, said legal problems related to new wind power projects put Germany’s climate targets at risk. “We need concerted action to simplify approval procedures,” said Zelinger. “The capacities put to auction have almost become secondary to capacity approvals.”
Zelinger said the landmark coal exit commission proposal was further proof that demand for renewable power was set to increase sharply in the future. He also pointed to recent announcements by large industry players who wanted to switch to green energy, naming carmaker VW and steelmaker Thyssenkrupp as examples.
VW said in December it planned the climate-neutral production of its upcoming electric model ID Neo, which is set to start next year. Thyssenkrupp last week unveiled plans to phase out CO₂-intensive coke-based steel production and replace it with a hydrogen-based process based on renewable energy by 2050.
“New factories or datacentres will no longer be built in regions without a supply of renewable energy,” Zelinger said. “It has become one of the key issues for the energy transition how much renewable power we will manage to produce.”
New installations slump
The roll-out of onshore wind power in Germany slowed sharply last year. Turbines with a total capacity of 2.4 gigawatts (GW) were connected to the grid, a drop of 55 percent, the lobby groups said. Germany’s total number of wind turbines on land increased by a net 538 to 29,213, increasing total capacity to almost 53 GW.
The industry association said they did not expect a market recovery before 2021, when additional special auctions will have an effect. “The short-term perspective for capacity additions from 2019 to 2020 remains weak,” VWE and VDMA said, adding they expected new additions to drop further to below 2 GW in 2019.
Germany holds regular onshore wind power auctions totalling 2.8 GW per year from 2017 to 2019 and 2.9 GW per year from 2020. Including additional special auctions agreed to last year, total auction capacities for onshore wind will amount to 3.675 GW in 2019, 4.1 GW in 2020 and 4.25 GW in 2021, according to BWE and VDMA. On top of these amounts, there are combined wind and solar auctions.